Harvey Weinstein trial stay: Mogul’s attorneys blame the accusers and says they ‘tried to cut the line’ for roles

Harvey Weinstein retrial set for opening statements

Disgraced film mogul Harvey Weinstein has returned to a New York courtroom for the opening day of his rape and sexual assault retrial.

Weinstein, who was wheeled into court in a wheelchair on Wednesday morning, is being tried again after New York’s highest court last year overturned his 2020 conviction and 23-year prison sentence in a major blow to the #MeToo movement.

State prosecutors brought a new charge against Weinstein in September: a criminal sexual act stemming from accusations from former model and aspiring actress Kaja Sokola. He is being retried on charges of rape and criminal sex act based on accusations from former TV production assistant, Miriam Haley, and aspiring actress, Jessica Mann.

The 73-year-old has pleaded not guilty.

In her opening statement on Wednesday, prosecutor Shannon Lucey recounted the claims of several accusers, telling them that Weinstein “didn’t take no for an answer.”

The court was also introduced to the account of Sokola, the third woman bringing forward allegations in Weinstein’s retrial. She did not testify in the previous trial.

Sokola was 16 at the time that she alleges Weinstein sexually assaulted her and is reportedly the youngest accuser to speak out against her.

Last week a judge ruled Weinstein could spend his retrial in a hospital rather than Rikers Island due to his extensive health issues.

Court adjourned for lunch

Court has been adjourned for a lunch break until 2.45 p.m.

We’ll start hearing witness testimony then.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:45

Defense lawyer says accusers only came forward after #MeToo

Aidala says that the women came forward with their accusations in 2017, following the advent of the #MeToo movement.

“Sorry Mr Weinstein,” he says, looking to his client, “but he wasn’t the most powerful man in Hollywood,” unlike Warner Bros and Paramount. “It’s not like if he didn’t give you a job, there was nowhere else to go.”

“There were no complaints before they started handing out the money,” he adds.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:39

Sketches from inside the courtroom

(REUTERS)
(REUTERS)
(REUTERS)
Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:35

Defense says trial is a circus that smells like ‘poop and pee’

Aidala is delivering a crazy long metaphor about the circus and how the prosecution wants jurors to be enthralled with the acrobatics and popcorn during direct examination.

But the defense, through cross-examination, is going to show you what really goes on, he adds, showing you “the smell…the poop and the pee” that is overwhelming at the circus.

You can’t make this up.

At one point the judge even said “I don’t know where you’re going with this” prompting laughter from the whole room.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:22

Female accusers are ‘manipulating’ and ‘conniving’ says defense

Aidala adds that the three female accusers are “smart, sophisticated women” as well as “manipulating” and “conniving.”

“They wanted to use Harvey when he’s at the top and they wanted to use Harvey when he’s at the bottom,” he says.

He argues the women didn’t go to police, a doctor, a hospital or a psychiatrist in the wake of the alleged encounters, before singling out high-profile lawyer Gloria Allred in the back row of the court.

“She’s one of the greats,” he says of Allred. Mimi picked her “because she’s known for suing men.”

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:15

Defense say new accuser’s story is ‘based on a lie’

In his opening statement, Aidala says that Kaja Sokola’s “whole story is based on a lie” and she has a “lot of problems.” The prosecution previously highlighted that she struggles with eating disorders and alcohol addiction.

“From her teens through 30, she doesn’t complain to a human being” about Weinstein, he says.

All three women have maintained “long-term relationships” with Weinstein that were “very friendly, very amicable,” Aidala adds, pointing to texts and emails that they wrote to him. They apparently wrote “miss you” and “love you” to Weinstein after these alleged crimes took place.

“They’re asking you to make sense of things that don’t make sense,” he tells the jury.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:08

Weinstein accusers ‘tried to cut the line,’ defense claims

Aidala tells the majority-female jury that Weinstein’s accusers had attempted to “cut the line” with their careers in the industry.

“They fooled around with him consensually. Jessica [Mann] fooled around with him probably more times than she can count,” he says.

In Hollywood, there was the casting couch. For these three women, “the casting couch was not a crime scene,” Aidala says. “Was it immoral? 100%.”

These women “tried to cut the line, they tried to take a shortcut… There’s a lot of real estate between immorality and criminality.”

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 18:03

Weinstein hailed as ‘greatest movie exec of his generation’ by defense attorney

In his statement Aidala waxes lyrical about Weinstein, dropping some of the biggest names in Hollywood including Gwyneth Paltrow and Meryl Streep.

“Although he doesn’t look like George Clooney or Leonardo DiCaprio or Brad Pitt, you’ll hear in their words how he’s charismatic and generous,” he says.

“A real argument can be made that he was the greatest movie executive, at the very least, of his generation.” Weinstein has been thanked at the Academy Awards as many times as God and Steven Spielberg, he adds.

“The charged crimes are minutes. The witnesses want you to read a page of that book…For context, you need to read the whole book. We want you to read the whole book and watch the whole movie,” Aidala says.

Each of the witnesses were “doing fine in their own right….They’re all good. And then through different circumstances, they meet Harvey Weinstein. According to them and according to us, he is a man who can make dreams come true.”

The accusers all all realized Weinstein had the key to get them into the room, Aidala says, adding the that they were “flirtatious.” “They wanted him. He could change the trajectory of their lives.”

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 17:58

Weinstein’s defense begins opening statements

Arthur Aidala, Weinstein’s defense attorney, started off his testimony by emphasizing that opening statements are not evidence or facts.

“There’s common sense and then there’s something that just doesn’t seem right to me. Their evidence just doesn’t seem right.” That’s reasonable doubt, he said.

“Folks, after you hear all the evidence, their case is going to fall flat on its face,” he adds.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 17:52

Prosecution’s opening statement concludes

The prosecution has concluded it’s opening statements.

This case is about “one of the most powerful men in show business,” Lucey said. She added that Weinstein was so used to getting what he wanted, “he was incapable of taking ‘no’ for an answer.”

There will now be a 10 minute recess before the defense makes its opening remarks.

Mike Bedigan23 April 2025 17:30

Source: independent.co.uk