Tennessee Takes Step Toward Letting People Refuse To Marry LGBTQ+ Couples


The Tennessee Senate handed a invoice Monday night that will enable individuals to refuse to carry out a wedding that they don’t personally agree with.

Senate Bill 596 says “a person shall not be required to solemnize a marriage if the person has an objection to solemnizing the marriage based on the person’s conscience or religious beliefs.”

State Rep. Monty Fritts (R), the sponsor of an equivalent companion invoice within the state House, mentioned final 12 months that the invoice was created “simply and clearly to protect the rights of the officiate or officiates of wedding ceremonies.”

However, Tennessee regulation at present doesn’t require anybody to officiate a wedding in the event that they don’t wish to.

The Senate invoice has been substituted with the equivalent House invoice. It will transfer on to the House for the subsequent vote.

This is the Republican-controlled legislature’s second try to push ahead a invoice that critics say may have widespread ramifications, together with for LGBTQ+ and interracial {couples}.

“The way it’s worded, you can discriminate against anybody for any reason, which is terrible,” mentioned Eric Patton, a Tennessee-based minister, instructed Nashville tv station WKRN. “The idea that you can discriminate against anybody is just wrong-headed and general Tennessee nonsense.”

Patton instructed the Nashville outlet that the “vaguely worded” laws is opening itself as much as lawsuits as a result of the state desires “to test the marriage equality law as it stands.”

The Human Rights Campaign and Tennessee Equality Project condemned this invoice and the state’s anti-drag invoice final 12 months.

Marriage equality has been a federally protected proper since 2015, when the Supreme Court dominated in Obergefell v. Hodges that same-sex marriage was constitutionally protected.

Same-sex and interracial marriages are additional protected by the Respect for Marriage Act, which President Joe Biden signed into regulation in 2022, repealing the Clinton-era Defense of Marriage Act and guaranteeing federal protections for same-sex {couples} throughout the nation.

Although it was heralded as the largest win for LGBTQ+ equality for the reason that repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” critics have mentioned the invoice didn’t go far sufficient and as an alternative pandered to spiritual organizations. An modification within the regulation carves out exceptions for non secular organizations to refuse to marry same-sex {couples}, and in addition permits non secular organizations to maintain their tax exempt standing and obtain federal advantages even when they select to refuse companies for a same-sex marriage.

Only two states, North Carolina and Mississippi, have legal guidelines on the books that enable state and native officers to refuse marriages with which they disagree.

Last 12 months Tennessee launched ― and handed ― extra anti-LGBTQ legal guidelines than some other state.

Cathryn Oakley, the director of authorized coverage on the Human Rights Campaign, characterised Tennessee as an “innovator” in anti-LGBTQ insurance policies.

“They try things early,” Oakley instructed Rolling Stone. “Sometimes they don’t pass them right away, but they’ve got a little bit of everything. They’re a lab for this stuff.”
Tennessee is chargeable for 29 of the greater than 415 anti-LGBTQ payments which have been launched in state legislatures to date this 12 months, in response to the American Civil Liberties Union’s legislative tracker.